Composting is one of those garden practices that sounds complicated until you actually try it — and then you wonder why you ever threw vegetable scraps in the trash. At its core, composting is just managed decomposition. You feed organic material to microbes and worms, they break it down, and over time you end up with one of the best soil amendments money can't buy.
This guide cuts through the noise and gives you what you actually need to start composting at home, whether you have a big backyard or a small apartment kitchen.
What Composting Actually Does for Your Garden
Finished compost — often called "black gold" by experienced growers — does more for your soil than almost any store-bought fertilizer. It improves drainage in clay-heavy soils and helps sandy soils retain moisture. It introduces beneficial microorganisms that suppress plant disease and improve nutrient uptake. It provides a slow, steady release of nutrients rather than the quick spike and crash of synthetic fertilizers.
Gardens amended with compost consistently produce more vigorous plants, better yields, and healthier root systems. And you're making it from waste you'd otherwise discard — it's one of the most efficient practices in home gardening.
The Simple Science: Browns, Greens, and Moisture
Composting works because of a balance between carbon-rich materials ("browns") and nitrogen-rich materials ("greens"). Carbon feeds the microbes that do the decomposition work. Nitrogen accelerates the process and provides the raw material for microbial growth. Too many browns and your pile decomposes slowly and produces little heat. Too many greens and it becomes wet, smelly, and anaerobic.
A rough ratio of 2–3 parts browns to 1 part greens by volume is a good target. You don't need to be precise — experienced composters adjust by feel and observation — but keeping this ratio in mind prevents most common problems.
What Counts as Browns
Dead leaves, cardboard (torn into pieces), newspaper, paper bags, straw, dried plant stems, wood chips, and paper egg cartons all qualify as brown materials. These tend to be dry and carbon-rich.
What Counts as Greens
Fruit and vegetable scraps, coffee grounds and filters, tea bags, fresh grass clippings, plant prunings, and garden weeds (that haven't gone to seed) are all nitrogen-rich green materials. Despite the name, not all greens are visually green — coffee grounds are an excellent nitrogen source despite being brown in color.
What to Avoid
Meat, fish, dairy, and cooked foods can attract pests and create unpleasant odors — skip these unless you're using a sealed, pest-proof system. Diseased plant material should not go into your compost pile, as the pathogens may survive and spread when you apply the finished compost. Pet waste carries bacteria that standard composting temperatures may not fully eliminate.
Choosing a Composting Method
There is no single right way to compost. The best method is whichever one you'll actually maintain consistently.
Open Bin or Pile
The simplest approach: designate a corner of your yard for a loose pile or use a simple three-sided bin made from pallets or wire mesh. Add materials as they become available, turn the pile every week or two to introduce oxygen, and keep it consistently moist but not waterlogged. In warm months, you can have finished compost in as little as six to eight weeks with regular turning.
Tumbler Composting
Compost tumblers are fully enclosed rotating drums mounted on a frame. They're neater than an open pile, faster in warm weather (heat builds up more efficiently), and completely pest-resistant. The tradeoff is cost — a good tumbler is an investment — and the need to batch your inputs, since adding fresh material constantly slows down the hot decomposition process.
Recommended: FCMP Outdoor Dual-Chamber Compost Tumbler
A top-rated tumbler with two separate chambers, allowing you to have one batch finishing while you load the other. Heavy-duty construction with excellent aeration. Works well in Wisconsin's variable climate.
Buy Now →This is an affiliate link. We may earn a commission if you purchase through it, at no extra cost to you.
Vermicomposting (Worm Composting)
For apartment dwellers or anyone without outdoor space, a worm bin is a clean, odorless option that fits under a kitchen counter. Red wiggler worms process food scraps incredibly fast and produce worm castings — one of the most nutrient-dense natural soil amendments available. A properly maintained worm bin produces no odor and is surprisingly low maintenance once established.
Maintaining Your Compost Pile
A neglected compost pile doesn't fail — it just takes much longer to produce finished material. Regular attention produces compost in weeks rather than months. Check moisture: the pile should feel like a wrung-out sponge. Turn the pile every one to two weeks to introduce oxygen and redistribute heat. Add new materials in layers rather than dumping a large batch of one thing at a time.
If your pile smells like ammonia, you have too many greens — add more browns and turn it. If it's dry and not breaking down, add water and some nitrogen-rich material. A pile that's working correctly generates heat at its center (sometimes up to 140°F), which you can feel by reaching into the middle with your hand or a probe thermometer.
Knowing When Your Compost Is Ready
Finished compost looks dark, crumbly, and earthy. It smells like forest soil — pleasant, not pungent. You should no longer be able to identify the original materials. It has a consistent, loamy texture. If you can still see recognizable pieces of food or paper, give it more time and keep the pile moist and turned.
If you're impatient, you can sift the pile and use the finished portions immediately while returning unfinished material to continue breaking down.
Using Your Finished Compost
Apply 1–3 inches of finished compost to garden beds and work it gently into the top several inches of soil before planting. You can top-dress established beds mid-season by spreading a thin layer around existing plants. Mix compost into potting soil at a ratio of about 20–30% for a nutritious container mix. Use it as a mulch around trees and shrubs to slowly feed the soil as it breaks down further.
Start a compost pile this week with whatever scraps you have on hand. In a few months, you'll be adding something genuinely valuable back into your garden — and sending almost nothing to the landfill in the process.